Barcelona Player Ratings vs Borussia Dortmund: Happy and Great FCB in the Semi Finals after 6 Years

Barcelona Player Ratings vs Borussia Dortmund, Barcelona faced a stern test in the Champions League quarter-final second leg at Signal Iduna Park, losing 3-1 to Borussia Dortmund but advancing with a 5-3 aggregate victory. Despite a commanding 4-0 win in the first leg, Hansi Flick’s side narrowly escaped elimination as Dortmund’s Serhou Guirassy delivered a stunning hat-trick. For fans and analysts seeking Barcelona player ratings vs Borussia Dortmund, this article provides an in-depth breakdown of individual performances, tactical insights, and what this result means for Barcelona’s European journey.

Barcelona arrived in Germany with a four-goal cushion from the first leg at Estadi Olimpic Lluis Companys, where Robert Lewandowski, Lamine Yamal, and Raphinha had shone brightly. However, Dortmund, led by Niko Kovac, turned the second leg into a battle, pushing Barcelona to the brink. Guirassy’s three goals highlighted Dortmund’s attacking prowess, but an own goal by Ramy Bensebaini—sparked by Fermin Lopez’s cross—proved decisive in securing Barcelona’s semi-final spot.

The match showcased contrasting fortunes: Barcelona’s defensive resilience clashed with their attacking struggles, particularly from Yamal and Raphinha. This analysis of Barcelona player ratings vs Borussia Dortmund reflects a team that survived more on grit than flair.

Barcelona Player Ratings vs Borussia Dortmund: Yamal and Raphinha Struggle as Blaugrana Survive Champions League Scare

Here’s how each Barcelona player performed in this pulsating Champions League encounter:

Goalkeeper & Defense

Wojciech Szczesny (7/10)
Szczesny’s night started with a misstep, conceding a penalty after fouling Pascal Gross in the 10th minute. Yet, he bounced back with critical saves, including a standout stop against Karim Adeyemi, earning a solid 7/10 in the Barcelona player ratings vs Borussia Dortmund.
Jules Kounde (5/10)
Kounde was exposed by Dortmund’s wingers, offering minimal defensive resistance and little support in attack. A disappointing outing.
Pau Cubarsi (5/10)
The young defender was overrun by Dortmund’s relentless pressure, struggling in duels and lacking his usual composure.
Ronald Araujo (6/10)
Araujo battled Adeyemi’s pace and made a vital clearance late in the game, though his error gifted Guirassy’s third goal. A mixed performance.
Gerard Martin (7/10)
Martin emerged as Barcelona’s defensive hero, disrupting Dortmund’s attacks with sharp interceptions and earning high marks in the Barcelona player ratings vs Borussia Dortmund.

Midfield

Gavi (6/10)
Gavi’s tenacity shone through with ball recoveries and smart passes, but his impact faded, leading to an early substitution.
Frenkie de Jong (7/10)
De Jong anchored the midfield, breaking up Dortmund’s plays and maintaining possession under pressure—a standout in a chaotic game.
Fermin Lopez (7/10)
Lopez’s cross forced Bensebaini’s own goal, a turning point that eased Barcelona’s nerves. His creativity was a rare positive.

Attack

Lamine Yamal (5/10)
Yamal had possession but couldn’t unlock Dortmund’s defense, fading as the game progressed. A lackluster 5/10.
Robert Lewandowski (4/10)
Against his former club, Lewandowski was isolated and ineffective, though his presence indirectly contributed to the own goal.
Raphinha (4/10)
Raphinha’s two weak shots summed up a frustrating night, earning him a 4/10 in the Barcelona player ratings vs Borussia Dortmund.

Key Moments That Shaped the Match

Penalty Drama (10th Minute)
Szczesny’s foul on Gross handed Guirassy an early opener, setting the tone for Dortmund’s resurgence.
Disallowed Goal (15th Minute)
Gross’s strike was ruled out for offside, a moment of relief for Barcelona’s shaky defense.
Guirassy’s Second (49th Minute)
A corner routine saw Guirassy head home, narrowing the aggregate gap and igniting the crowd.
Bensebaini’s Own Goal (54th Minute)
Lopez’s delivery led to Bensebaini’s costly error, restoring Barcelona’s breathing room.
Hat-Trick Heroics (80th Minute)
Araujo’s clearance blunder allowed Guirassy to complete his hat-trick, but time ran out for Dortmund.

These moments define the Barcelona player ratings vs Borussia Dortmund, showcasing both resilience and vulnerability.

Tactical Insights: How Flick’s Plan Survived the Storm

Hansi Flick’s 4-3-3, so dominant in the first leg, buckled under Dortmund’s high-pressing 4-2-3-1. Adeyemi and Gross exploited the flanks, while Barcelona’s midfield struggled to dictate play. Yamal and Raphinha were marooned, leaving Lewandowski isolated. Flick’s adjustment to push Lopez forward paid dividends with the own goal, but the Barcelona player ratings vs Borussia Dortmund reveal a team that leaned heavily on luck and individual efforts.

Fan Reactions: Mixed Emotions After a Close Call

Social media buzzed with Barcelona fans’ reactions. “First leg saved us,” one tweeted, while another lamented, “Yamal and Raphinha were ghosts.” Szczesny and Martin earned praise, reflecting their strong showings in the Barcelona player ratings vs Borussia Dortmund.

What This Means for Barcelona’s Champions League Hopes

Advancing to the semi-finals against either Bayern Munich or Inter Milan is a triumph, but Dortmund exposed cracks. Defensive lapses and an impotent attack—evident in Yamal and Raphinha’s ratings—signal work ahead for Flick. The Barcelona player ratings vs Borussia Dortmund highlight the need for tactical tweaks to sustain their treble chase.

Conclusion

The Barcelona player ratings vs Borussia Dortmund paint a picture of a team that scraped through a Champions League scare. Martin, De Jong, and Szczesny stood tall, but Yamal and Raphinha’s struggles underscored a disjointed performance. Dortmund’s Guirassy nearly orchestrated a miracle, yet Barcelona’s first-leg heroics held firm. As the semi-finals loom, Flick must address these shortcomings to keep Barcelona’s European dreams alive. Share your thoughts on the ratings below!

Dortmund are now rooting for Barcelona to win the UCL 👀🤝 pic.twitter.com/jsvibkCyqg

— 433 (@433) April 16, 2025

FAQs: Barcelona Player Ratings vs Borussia Dortmund

Who was Barcelona’s best player against Dortmund?
Gerard Martin’s 7/10 rating marked him as the standout, thwarting Dortmund’s attacks.
Why did Lamine Yamal and Raphinha underperform?
Dortmund’s tight marking and lack of midfield support left them isolated and ineffective.
How did Barcelona survive the Dortmund onslaught?
A 4-0 first-leg lead and Bensebaini’s own goal provided the buffer despite a 3-1 loss.
What’s next for Barcelona in the Champions League?
They’ll face Bayern Munich or Inter Milan in the semi-finals, a stern test of their credentials.
How impactful was Serhou Guirassy’s hat-trick?
It nearly flipped the tie, but Dortmund fell short of overturning the aggregate deficit.